An Englishman walks into a Bundesliga Club…

1 Jun

Mancienne has signed a four-year deal at HSV

One may mistake the title for the start of a poorly crafted joke. But such jokes are all too common and often over-told. This story however, is not.

This week Michael Mancienne was excused from England Under-21 training to sign a four-year deal at Hamburg, for a fee believed to be around £1.75m. Having spent the past two years on loan at Wolves, the versatile 23 year old joins the port-city club on the back of HSV sporting director (formerly of Chelsea), Frank Arnesen’s recommendation. On joining HSV, the London born defender had this to say:

“Hamburg are a big club with a lot of tradition and some fantastic fans. It’s a big challenge for me to be able to play for this club. It would be great if I could play a part in helping Hamburg get back into Europe.”

He’s right. Joining Hamburg will be a huge challenge for Mancienne. After all, the last Englishman to play there happened to be Kevin Keegan, who led the club to their first Bundesliga crown and won two European Player of the Year’s whilst he was at it. 

Keegan was the first and previously only Englishman to join HSV

Mancienne will be hoping to make a better start that Keegan – who was sent off for punching a VfL Lübeck player in a pre-season friendly and finished 10th in his first season. Michael Oenning’s side will be seeking a top 6 finish which should get them a Europa League spot at the bare minimum.

So Mancienne’s move makes him only the second English player in HSV’s history. This is a trend recurring across the whole of Germany. With only sporadic appearances of British players – Paul Lambert at Borussia Dortmund for example – at best, the Bundesliga has never really appealed to players of this shore. Having said that, it’s a similar story right across Europe, with no Englishmen in Serie A, Ligue 1 or La Liga. But why?

English players have long been thought overpriced. Why buy Andy Carroll for £35m when you could get Lucas Barrios for €4m? That does provide a sufficient explanation for the high-end players, but why don’t more fringe players like Mancienne make the move? Are they unwilling to leave home and learn a new language? Content to warm the bench? Are they just technically deficient? Are they worried that a move will kill any hope of an international call-up?

One theory is that the ‘success’ of the Premier League has warped players into thinking that they’re in the right place. That if they stay at a club long-enough they’ll eventually get a first-team opportunity. With some Premier League bosses unwilling to loan to other sides in the league, the Bundesliga should provide a good option for young players, but it doesn’t appear to do so.

Mancienne should be admired. He’s taken a bold step into the unknown to broaden his footballing education, and although he may be joined by other Chelsea products in the form of Patrick van Aanholt or Jeffrey Bruma, signing a four-year deal shows a willingness to succeed in his chosen path. Perhaps he’s smart. With Germany’s ever-improving UEFA co-efficient, the Bundesliga will have four Champions League places next term and Hamburg will fancy their chances of nabbing a spot.

With Josh McEachran also rumoured to be mulling over a move to HSV, the tide could well be changing. Or it could just be a case of Arnesen having a Chelsea-limited contact book.


2 Responses to “An Englishman walks into a Bundesliga Club…”

  1. trequartista 04/06/2011 at 1:46 pm #

    i wish him all the best and i hope he does well at HSV. and sala as well. arnesen is on a roll.

    and josh wouldnt think about the prospects of leaving to HSV, let alone germany, let alone saying bye to chelsea. a loan deal may happen – but hes currently being groomed by the club to be the next stamford bridge icon after JT and Lampard. and he certainly doesnt want to leave any time soon.

    of course the future isnt certain, but i just think its highly unlikely.

    • trequartista 04/06/2011 at 1:48 pm #

      oh forgot to add that this is a trend i fully support. bundesliga needs a bit more coverage and theres so much talent being wasted away on benches + reserves etc in england – where its really tough to break into the first team. too many superstars, too many divas.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: